Billionaire tax goes to midterm ballot, leaving California’s economic future to voters

Show summary Hide summary

California voters will decide whether to approve Proposition 40, a proposed one-time “billionaire tax” that would levy 5% on individual and trust assets above $1 billion to fund healthcare, education and food assistance — a measure supporters say could raise roughly $100 billion but that some economists warn may shrink the state’s tax base and produce a net revenue loss.

What the measure would do

Proposition 40, as drafted, would apply a one-time 5% levy on covered assets exceeding $1 billion, payable over five years. Covered holdings would include businesses, securities, art, collectibles and intellectual property; real property, pensions and certain retirement accounts would be exempt. The proposal would apply retroactively to people who were California residents on Jan. 1, 2026.

Stack of papers and a calculator representing proposed wealth levy details
The draft of Proposition 40 would tax assets above $1 billion with exemptions for some holdings.

Competing estimates on revenue and mobility

Supporters point to a working paper by UC Berkeley economists Gabriel Zucman and Emmanuel Saez with Jasper Boll of the Paris School of Economics, which estimated the levy could raise about $100 billion over the five-year collection window and have “comparatively minor impacts on income tax revenue,” because billionaires’ income-tax contributions are a small share of the state income tax base.

Two economists reviewing research papers and charts in an office
Competing working papers offer sharply different revenue and mobility forecasts for the proposal.

But a working paper by Hoover Institution economists Joshua Rauh and Benjamin Jaros reached a much different conclusion. The Hoover researchers estimated that announced departures and other behavioral responses have already reduced the taxable billionaire wealth base by roughly 30 percent. After accounting for assumed avoidance, they projected collections in the $28 billion to $36 billion range and calculated a net present value (NPV) loss of $38.9 billion from permanently reduced future income-tax receipts.

Rauh and Jaros reported that the NPV of the policy would be negative in about 85 percent of their simulated outcomes, and only modestly positive in roughly 15 percent. Their NPV analysis used an estimate of billionaire contributions to California income taxes — between about $3.3 billion and $5.8 billion per year — to measure the long-term cost of those who leave or reduce taxable activity.

Reactions and possible effects

The proposal has prompted public warnings from business leaders and prompted some wealthy individuals to change residency or business arrangements. The measure “has caused some prominent billionaires to move out of the state or relocate businesses,” the reporting noted, naming Google co‑founders Larry Page and Sergey Brin, Oracle founder Larry Ellison and PayPal co‑founder Peter Thiel among those who have shifted assets or operations. California governor Gavin Newsom has expressed opposition, citing concerns about outmigration.

Affirm co‑founder and CEO Max Levchin told Bloomberg he would “probably” leave California if voters approve the wealth tax, adding, “I love California. I think it’s beautiful. But the notion of the popular opinion saying ‘Actually, we’re totally OK with asset seizure because we just really, really need it,’ I just think that is so wrong.”

Proponents argue the levy targets wealth held in non‑wage forms and would generate substantial resources for public programs even after some departures. Zucman, Saez and Boll wrote that, using empirical estimates of mobility responses, a wealth tax “could raise substantial additional revenue even after accounting for income tax losses due to mobility.”

Rauh and Jaros cautioned that the billionaire tax’s one‑time framing does not necessarily preclude future changes: they noted the legislature could, with a two‑thirds vote, amend the law and potentially impose further wealth taxes without returning to voters.

The competing working papers illustrate the range of outcomes analysts see for Proposition 40, with widely different assumptions about how wealthy individuals respond to the tax and how much revenue would be collected and retained in California over time.

Give your feedback

Be the first to rate this post
or leave a detailed review



Colombia Politics is an independent media. Support us by adding us to your Google News favorites:

Post a comment

Publish a comment